No decision on speeding up Afghan troop withdrawal in 2013

Patrick Wintour
Friday, 16-December-2011
British troops in Helmand province: the National Security Council reaffirmed plans for all UK combat forces to leave Afghanistan by the end of 2014. Photograph: Sgt Wes Calder RLC/PA/MoD

 

Meeting of National Security Council holds back from endorsing plans for swifter drawdown next year


A special meeting of the government's National Security Council (NSC) has reaffirmed plans for all UK combat troops to leave Afghanistan by the end of 2014, but held back from endorsing plans for an additional withdrawal next year beyond the 500 troops already announced by David Cameron. The NSC also examined options for a swifter drawdown in 2013, but no decision was made.

The stocktaking session lasted two hours and focused on the chances of hastening reconciliation between the Taliban and the Karzai government.

There had been options on the table to speed up troop withdrawals in 2013 on the basis that it might in turn expedite the process of reconciliation, as well as force the Afghan army to take further control of security in the country. Cost savings would also be made.

The extended meeting heard from three independent experts: Michael Semple, a Harvard professor and expert on Pashtun Afghans; Bruce Riedel, a senior fellow in foreign policy from the Saban Centre at the Brookings Institution; and Anatole Lieven, the chair of international relations and terrorism studies at King's College London.

Riedel chaired an interagency review of policy towards Afghanistan and Pakistan for the White House that was completed in March 2009. Semple has long been an advocate of talking to the Taliban.

The prime minister's special envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan, Mark Sedwill, also addressed the meeting.

The presence of independent experts may have been designed to provide the NSC with a counterweight to the sometimes-Panglossian assessment by British military chiefs that victory is imminent.

There has been a widespread view inside government for more than two years that NATO military forces are unlikely to prevail – but, equally, that the Taliban cannot assassinate their way to victory.

Under proposals discussed at the meeting, the number of UK troops in Helmand province would be cut from 9,000 to 5,000 in 2013, and almost the same number would withdraw the following year – leaving a few hundred in Kabul when NATO ends its combat role in 2014.
But plans to speed up the pullout would be in defiance of NATO commanders leading the International Security and Assistance Force in Kabul. They have advised a more cautious approach, and are urging all NATO countries – most importantly the US – to delay any further troop withdrawals to the end of 2013 so NATO forces can contribute to another full "fighting season". The troop freeze is deemed important to keep the coalition from fracturing.

The possibility that US president, Barack Obama, might decide to speed up his own troop withdrawal plans next year was also discussed at the meeting, but the consensus is that, in an election year, Obama is unlikely to go against the advice of his military chiefs, who favor the current troop drawdown timetable.

Cameron's spokesman said no decisions on accelerating troop withdrawals were made, adding that the UK combat role will end in 2014.

Sedwill has predicted that in 2020 "Afghanistan will not be a safe haven for al-Qaida and whatever remains of the insurgency should no longer pose a mortal threat to the Afghan state. The lives of most Afghans will still be dominated by poverty rather than insecurity, illiteracy will still be high, and children will still be at risk from respiratory and diarrheal diseases which are responsible for the highest infant mortality rate in the world. But economic growth should be lifting more Afghans out of subsistence poverty."

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 



    

Top Stories

Punjab govt. seeks four-month time for LB polls

ISLAMABAD: Punjab government has sought four-month time from Supreme Court (SC) for holding local bodies election in the...

Car bombings kill at least 33 people in Iraq

BAGHDAD: A new wave of car bombs ripped through commercial areas in the Iraqi capital and areas to the south Tuesday, ki...

Altaf, Zardari discuss law & order in Sindh

KARACHI: Muttahidat Qaumi Movement (MQM) chief Altaf Hussain and former president and co-chairman of Pakistan Peoples Pa...

White House weighs petition to deport Justin Bieber

WASHINGTON: As if Barack Obama didn't have enough problems to deal with already, his administration now is being asked t...

Sindh CNG stations reopen after 24 hours

KARACHI: CNG stations across Sindh including Karachi reopened after 24-hour closure at 8:00 AM today (Tuesday), media re...

Gas leakage blast kills 1, hurts 3 in Quetta

QUETTA: An explosion occurred at a house due to gas leakage, killing at least one person and wounding three others here ...

Ministry of CAD decisions put students,teachers & parents in a fix

Islamabad:Ministry of Capital Administration and Development (CAD) indecisive attitude put the students as well as paren...

10-year-old maid allegedly tortured to death in Lahore

LAHORE: A 10-year-old girl, who works as maid, was allegedly tortured to death in Lahore, medi reported.Sources said tha...

Five friends voluntarily embrace death: police

THATTA: Police after initial investigation claimed that five friends, who were allegedly killed in Noori Jam Tamachi, vo...

Pakistan wants good relations with all neighbouring countries: PM Nawaz

ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has said that Pakistan wanted good relations with all the neighbouring countries....

IHC dismisses Musharaf’s pleas; verdict issued

ISLAMABAD: Islamabad High Court (IHC) on Thursday issued 11-page detailed verdict over the intra-court appeal filed by f...

Pakistan to get $550m after IMF review meeting on Dec. 19

WASHINGTON: International Monetary Fund (IMF) first quarter review meeting on Pakistan’s loan programme will be held on...

Kayani thanks Corps Commanders for extending support

RAWALPINDI: The 166th Corps Commanders Conference was held at General Headquarters on Thursday.   Outgoing Chief of Ar...

3 women held captive for 30 years: UK police

LONDON: Three women have been freed after spending 30 years held captive in a south London home, including one woman be...

Iran has slowed work on atomic facilities: IAEA

NEW YORK: Iran appears to have dramatically slowed work on its atomic energy program since the summer, U.N. officials s...

Young Frenchman too heavy to fly will go home by ship

NEW YORK CITY: A young Frenchman who weighs 230 kilograms (500 pounds) and was deemed too heavy to fly on a jetliner ar...

Ex-military ruler Pervez Musharraf released

ISLAMABAD: Adiala Jail authorities have formally released the country’s former military strongman General (retd) Pervez...

Bolivia coca ambush leaves 4 security force members dead

LA PAZ: A weekend ambush and hostage-taking involving police and Bolivian coca growers has left four people dead, offic...

Muslim pilgrims ritually stone devil as hajj nears end

MINA: Throngs of Muslim pilgrims took part in devil-stoning ritual for a second day Wednesday in Saudi Arabia's Mina Va...

KP Home Department orders police to collect data of internet cafes

PESHAWAR: The Home Department of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province has ordered police to collect the record of all the intern...


Feature / Analysis

  • Afghan Couple Find Idyllic Hide-Out in Mountains, but Not for Long

    HINDU KUSH RANGE, Afghanistan: They eloped from their village in the B...

    Read More »

  • Guantánamo Bay detainees' release upon end of Afghanistan war 'unlikely'

    US officials indicate fate of inmates captured during the country's lo...

    Read More »

  • Trailing candidates in Afghan election hold power in deciding next president

    KABUL: Some of the influential politicians who competed in Afghanistan...

    Read More »

  • Lessons Obtained from Afghan Presidential Polls 2014

    Preface History- When, Nadir Khan, the father of Zahir Shah the last k...

    Read More »


Opinion

  • Bridging the abyss

    DESCRIBING his experience of blindness, Prof John Hull of Birmingham U...

    Read More »

  • USAID documents cite Hillary Clinton in chaos of Afghan aid

    Despite waiver, reviews find U.S. money at riskIn internal government ...

    Read More »

  • Why a Regional Security Force Will Not Work in Afghanistan

    Talk of a new regional force is unrealistic. There is only one way to ...

    Read More »

  • Afghan election: Why the Taliban will win

    The West invaded Afghanistan, but Pakistan may have been the "true ene...

    Read More »